Heating, across buildings and industry accounts for approximately 25% of UK territorial emissions. Despite its size, second only to emissions from transport, responsibility for decarbonising heat in our homes, offices and industry has for many years been highly diffuse, shared between a variety of local, regional and national stakeholders (Ref to Peacock and Britton report). Progress over the last two decades has been slow. The shift towards Strategic Energy Planning, and Regional Energy Strategic Planning in particular (RESP), has the potential to change this.
As part of a new whole-system approach to energy planning, RESPs will have diverse, and uncertain, implications for how heat is decarbonised in English villages, Welsh Valleys, Scottish islands and major cities. RESP boards and working groups are currently being established in Wales, Scotland and nine English regions. From late 2026, development of the first full RESP will commence. Final plans are expected by the end of 2028.
But RESPs are not the only planning framework affecting clean heat planning and delivery. Several other approaches already exist. They include: Local Heat and Energy Efficiency strategies (LHEES) in Scotland which are limited to heat but exclude industry needs; Heat network zoning (HNZ) in England, also limited to heat but including industry, and Local Area Energy Planning (LAEP), which like RESP is a whole system approach. RESPs are the latest addition and their implications for heat planning are still emerging, raising the question: who has responsibility for clean heat planning and delivery in Britain?
This Working Paper addresses this question by introducing five institutional maps. Each map is constructed through the analysis of policy and practice documents. Four maps cover the key actors, roles and relationships in Regional Energy Strategic Planning, Local Heat and Energy Efficiency Strategies, Local Area Energy Planning and England’s heat network zoning. The fifth shows the emerging interfaces between these planning arenas. Collectively they illustrate, and raise questions about, different patterning of responsibilities for clean heat planning and delivery.
Across the four planning arenas more than 30 stakeholders are implicated in clean heat planning and delivery. These stakeholders reside across local, regional and national scales and their interactions are numerous.
Authority for clean heat planning is generally assigned to one stakeholder within each planning area. Local authorities lead three out of four arenas. The development of LHEES in Scotland and LAEPs in Wales are a statutory responsibility of local authorities. Authority for heat network zoning in England resides with the national Heat Network Zones Authority and heat network coordination bodies, in which local authorities are expected to play a central role. Through these arenas clean heat planning is concentrated at more local scales. RESP is the exception, operating at a regional, or devolved national, scale with authority for energy planning a delegated responsibility of NESO. Responsibility for clean heat planning therefore resides with multiple stakeholders, the extent of their autonomy and interactions determining the polycentric or hierarchical nature of system operation.
Responsibility for clean heat delivery is, by contrast, less clearly defined. From network businesses upgrading pipes and wires, heat network developers digging up roads or social landlords installing heat pumps, multiple stakeholders are implicated in delivery. RESPs, like prior planning frameworks, are expected to play a ‘direction-setting’ role. But beyond energy network companies, who are required to align their network planning to RESP outputs , no other stakeholders have their role(s) in clean heat delivery clearly articulated. Whilst transitional RESPs, launched in early 2026, were designed for energy network companies, full RESPs will need to assign roles for many more stakeholders.
The maps show planning arrangements as formally designed, not as they operate in practice. We expected the full RESP methodology, which has not yet been published at the time of writing, to clarify some of these roles and relationships. Further, we expect these design blueprints to evolve and change substantially as RESP governing boards, working groups and wider stakeholder processes are established. How stakeholders experience the next stage of RESP, in which RESP boards and working groups are established, is the next phase of our research.
For now we invite you to use, challenge and revise these maps. What changes to these maps would you make, given your experience of clean heating planning to date?
In your opinion what are the most critical connections or overlaps between planning arenas? Given your experience which actor(s) are best placed to lead clean heat planning and delivery? And In your view would a hierarchical or polycentric system create more effective governance arrangements?
Each map is available as an editable Miro board: duplicate it, adjust or annotate it to reflect your own understanding, and send us your version. If you spot omissions or errors, or would like to share any comments, please email Jake Barnes.